Gifted child guide
Giftedness and learning disorders: can a child have high potential and a learning disorder?
Yes, a child can have high intellectual abilities and a specific learning disorder. This coexistence is often described as “twice-exceptionality.”
Strengths can sometimes partly compensate for a difficulty, making results acceptable despite considerable effort. Conversely, the difficulty may lead to some abilities being underestimated.
The French umbrella term “DYS” covers several different conditions. The most direct evidence here mainly concerns dyslexia and broader groups of gifted students with learning disorders; it should not be generalized indiscriminately to every disorder.

Strengths and difficulties
High ability in one domain does not cancel out a specific difficulty in another.
Two dimensions can coexist without canceling each other out
The review by Kranz, Serry, and Snow specifically concerns gifted children with dyslexia. It describes difficulties in word reading, fluency, and spelling despite strengths, particularly in oral language, that may support partial compensation.
The literature on giftedness with learning disorders remains limited, with varying definitions and criteria. It nevertheless supports examining general abilities and performance in targeted learning areas separately.
Strength
Reasoning, vocabulary, or knowledge may be strong in certain domains.
A specific difficulty
Reading, spelling, or math may require disproportionate and persistent effort.
Compensation
An effective strategy may make a difficulty less visible without making it disappear.
Which contrasts may call for further exploration?
- accurate but very slow or exhausting reading
- persistently weak spelling despite instruction
- a marked contrast between oral expression and writing
- strong comprehension but difficulty with automatic skills
- results that vary greatly with time or format
- a persistent gap despite appropriate educational support

Assess each area
A targeted assessment distinguishes learning, cognitive functioning, and compensatory strategies.
Why targeted assessment is needed
An appropriate assessment examines developmental and school history, the learning areas involved, strategies, impact, and other possible explanations. Intellectual tests and tests of reading, spelling, or math do not answer the same question.
The neuropsychological review by Bucaille and colleagues highlights the heterogeneity of intellectually gifted children’s profiles. It does not provide a single cognitive profile that automatically identifies a disorder.
General ability does not erase a specific skill difficulty
Reading, spelling, writing, and math involve specialized learning. Advanced reasoning may help a child understand a text’s meaning, infer a word from context, or develop strategies without removing a persistent difficulty in decoding, spelling, or automatic skills.
This coexistence explains some contrasting profiles: the child participates brilliantly in oral discussion but reads slowly, understands a complex problem but makes basic calculation errors, or has rich ideas while writing requires great effort. The contrast deserves a domain-by-domain description rather than “They can when they want to.”
The French term “DYS” groups together several different disorders. Evidence on giftedness and dyslexia cannot automatically be applied to dyscalculia, language, or coordination. In English, these questions are more naturally discussed using terms such as learning disorders and reading or spelling difficulties.
How a difficulty can remain invisible for a long time
Good memory, rich vocabulary, contextual cues, and substantial family involvement can compensate for part of the difficulty. Results remain acceptable, but the time, fatigue, and strategies required are disproportionate. When texts get longer or independence increases, compensation may no longer be enough.
The reverse mechanism also exists: poor performance in one area leads others to underestimate reasoning abilities. Children may be defined by their mistakes, offered fewer complex tasks, and eventually doubt their own resources.
Recognizing twice-exceptionality therefore requires attention to both strengths and difficulties. An assessment looking only for weakness or only for giftedness risks missing the functional profile the school and family need.
Compensation
Strengths maintain performance but at the cost of considerable effort and fatigue.
Reverse masking
The specific difficulty leads to underestimating abilities present in other domains.
Contrast
Differences among oral and written work, speed, accuracy, or reasoning guide exploration without establishing a diagnosis.
Assess and support both dimensions
A targeted learning assessment examines the skills involved using suitable tools. It cannot be inferred from an IQ score, and an intellectual assessment does not replace examination of reading, language, spelling, or math. Several professionals may be involved depending on the question.
Accommodations should address the observed burden without removing access to complexity. A child may need writing support while benefiting from intellectually demanding content. Simplifying every task because of the difficulty risks reducing learning opportunities and feeding disengagement.
The explanation given to the child should preserve this dual perspective: a real difficulty is neither a lack of effort nor proof of low ability. Significant strengths do not mean they should compensate for everything alone. Support aims to provide access to learning and develop lasting strategies.
Match accommodations to the skill actually being assessed
An accommodation is not intended to make every task easy. It reduces the impact of a difficulty when that difficulty is not the main focus of the assessment. Assisted reading may be appropriate when checking comprehension of a text; when assessing decoding specifically, it would change the skill being measured.
This distinction allows expectations to remain ambitious. Children can access rich vocabulary, complex problems, and in-depth projects while benefiting from suitable time, tools, or response formats. Supporting a weaker area does not require reducing the intellectual content.
Digital tools can ease writing or reading, but their use must be learned. Text-to-speech, a spellchecker, or structured note-taking sometimes adds a new demand at first. Their effectiveness should be checked in actual tasks rather than assumed because they are available.
Coordination among family, school, and professionals prevents conflicting goals. Everyone should know which skill is being developed, which compensations are allowed, and how independence will progress. An overly complex plan, or one followed only on certain days, provides little security.
Finally, children need an accessible explanation of their profile. Naming a specific difficulty can bring relief, provided it is not treated as a permanent limit. They can understand that some learning paths require different tools and that their abilities remain available to build strategies.
Scenario: excellent comprehension, but persistently slow reading
The child understands a text in depth when listening to it, but independent reading remains slow and tiring. Context and knowledge may help them guess some words, masking some errors without making decoding automatic.
Assessment should compare listening comprehension, accuracy, speed, error types, and progress with instruction. A conclusion based only on rich answers or an overall grade would miss the specific skill.
During the investigation, access to content can be maintained through listening or other formats while reading is developed with the relevant professionals. Accommodation and targeted learning serve two complementary goals.
Preserve motivation during what may be a lengthy investigation
The process may involve several appointments and waiting between observation, assessment, and accommodations. Meanwhile, the child continues to encounter difficult tasks. An interim solution can limit repeated failure without prejudging the diagnostic conclusion.
Effort needs to be distributed. Adding many exercises after a demanding day may reduce readiness and increase conflicts. The professional and school can help choose the priority skill, practice frequency, and duration compatible with the rest of schooling.
Activities in which children use their strengths are not a distraction. They maintain a sense of competence, offer opportunities for complex reasoning, and prevent the whole relationship with school from becoming remediation.
Progress may be slow and uneven. Comparing children with their own past performance, and considering accuracy, fluency, strategies, and fatigue, provides a fairer reading than expecting them to catch up with the group immediately.
If children increasingly refuse learning activities or strongly devalue themselves, support should include the emotional impact. Addressing the specific skill without considering the accumulated experience of difficulty would leave an important part of the problem untouched.
Next step
01
Document
gather examples, work samples, time taken, and strategies used
02
Discuss
compare observations from the child, family, and school
03
Seek guidance
request an assessment specific to the learning areas involved
Cereya Giftedness
Explore cognitive functioning without diagnosing learning disorders
Cereya Gifted Child offers an initial informative exploration of your child’s cognitive functioning through a parent questionnaire and brief age-appropriate exercises.
The assessment does not measure boredom, anxiety, learning, or self-esteem, does not report an IQ score, and replaces neither a professional assessment nor a conversation with the school.
- age-appropriate parent questionnaire
- brief cognitive exercises for the child
- results organized by dimension
- clearly explained assessment limitations
Initial summary included; detailed analysis available afterward.

Distinct questions
Giftedness, attention, and learning require different assessments when a difficulty persists.
FAQ
Frequently asked questions
Can a child be gifted and dyslexic?+
Yes. General intellectual abilities and specific reading skills are not the same thing. They should be assessed separately.
Can giftedness mask dyslexia?+
Some strengths and strategies can partly compensate for difficulties, sometimes enough to delay recognition. This mechanism is neither systematic nor inferable from an impression alone.
Can dyslexia mask giftedness?+
A marked difficulty can lead to certain abilities being underestimated if assessment relies too heavily on affected performance. A multidimensional interpretation is therefore important.
Are all learning disorders studied in the same way alongside giftedness?+
No. The literature is particularly developed for dyslexia and remains more limited or heterogeneous for other specific learning disorders.
Do good grades rule out a learning disorder?+
No. They may be achieved through substantial effort, time, or compensatory strategies. The process and impact need to be examined.
Can the Cereya test diagnose a learning disorder?+
No. It does not replace targeted assessment of reading, spelling, math, or another learning area by appropriate professionals.
References and resources
The most direct evidence concerns dyslexia in gifted children; generalization to other learning disorders remains limited.
- Kranz, A. E., Serry, T. A. & Snow, P. C. (2024). Twice-exceptionality unmasked: A systematic narrative review of the literature on identifying dyslexia in the gifted child. Dyslexia, 30(1), e1763. DOI: 10.1002/dys.1763. PMID: 38232949.
- Beckmann, E. & Minnaert, A. (2018). Non-Cognitive Characteristics of Gifted Students With Learning Disabilities: An In-depth Systematic Review. Frontiers in Psychology, 9, 504. DOI: 10.3389/fpsyg.2018.00504. PMID: 29731728.
- Bucaille, A., Jarry, C., Allard, J., Brochard, S., Peudenier, S. & Roy, A. (2022). Neuropsychological Profile of Intellectually Gifted Children: A Systematic Review. Journal of the International Neuropsychological Society, 28(4), 424–440. DOI: 10.1017/S1355617721000515. PMID: 33998437.
- Kontakou, A., Dimitriou, G., Panagouli, E., Thomaidis, L., Psaltopoulou, T., Sergentanis, T. N. & Tsitsika, A. (2022). Giftedness and Neurodevelopmental Disorders in Children and Adolescents: A Systematic Review. Journal of Developmental & Behavioral Pediatrics, 43(7), e483–e497. DOI: 10.1097/DBP.0000000000001103. PMID: 36040826.
Explore further